Does it cost more to refinish cabinets or buy new ones?

Introduction

When updating their kitchen or bathroom, one of the most significant decisions homeowners face is whether to refinish their existing cabinets or invest in brand-new ones.

The answer to this question often hinges on various factors, including budget, aesthetics, and the overall condition of their cabinetry. In this blog article, we'll delve into the comparative costs and benefits of refinishing cabinets versus purchasing new ones, helping you make an informed decision that aligns with your financial and design goals.

The cost of refinishing cabinets

Refinishing cabinets is typically considered a more economical option than buying new ones. On average, homeowners can expect to pay between $1,500 to $4,500 to refinish their cabinets, depending on the size of the kitchen, the materials involved, and the job's complexity. Here’s a breakdown of some of the costs associated with refinishing:

• Labor costs. Professional painters or refinishing specialists charge for their expertise. Labor costs can range from $40 to $100 per hour, depending on the region and the contractor's experience. Hiring specialists ensures that the job is done correctly, prolonging the life of your cabinets.

• Materials. The materials used for refinishing can include primers, paints, stains, and sealants. High-quality materials can cost between $300 to $800, depending on the type and finish you choose. For instance, using a high-end, durable paint can enhance the longevity of your refinished cabinets.

• Prep work. The preparation phase is critical in refinishing cabinets. This includes removing cabinet doors and hardware, sanding surfaces, and ensuring a clean working environment. Additional prep work may also involve repairing damaged surfaces, adding to the overall cost.

• Time required. Refinishing cabinets takes a lot of work. Depending on the size of the kitchen and the refinishing technique employed, homeowners should expect the project to last anywhere from a few days to a couple of weeks.

The cost of buying new cabinets

On the other hand, purchasing new cabinets can be significantly more expensive, typically ranging from $5,000 to $20,000 or more. This price fluctuation depends on several factors:

• Material and style. The choice of materials plays a massive role in the price. Stock cabinets made of less expensive materials may start at the lower end, while custom or semi-custom cabinets made from solid wood can exceed $15,000. Choosing finishes, styles, and features—like soft-close hinges or built-in organizers—raises costs.

• Installation fees. If you hire a professional to install your new cabinets, expect to spend anywhere from $500 to $2,500 for installation labor, depending on the complexity and size of your kitchen design.

• Additional expenses. When acquiring new cabinets, additional costs may be considered. These may include demolishing and disposing of old cabinets, updating plumbing or electrical work, and costs associated with new countertops, which typically accompany a cabinet upgrade.

Refinishing existing cabinets

Pros

• Cost-effective. Generally more affordable than new cabinets.

• Sustainable choice. Refinishing is eco-friendly as it reduces waste by reusing existing materials.

• Customization. It offers the chance to change colors and finishes without the expense of new cabinetry.

Cons

• Limited changes. Refinishing does not alter the layout or design of cabinets, so if you're looking for a complete redesign, more is needed.

• Condition dependent. The success of refinishing depends on the underlying condition of the cabinets. If they are severely damaged or warped, refinishing may not be worthwhile.

Buying new cabinets

Pros

• Total transformation. New cabinets provide an opportunity for design upgrades and layout changes, allowing for a fresh look.

• Warranty. Most new cabinets come with warranties, ensuring peace of mind regarding their longevity.

Cons

• Higher cost. The upfront investment is considerably more than refinishing.

• Time-consuming. Ordering and installing new cabinets can take longer than refinishing existing ones, leading to a more extended disruption of your space.

Other factors

When deciding between refinishing and replacing cabinets, several factors should be considered:

• Budget. Assess how much you're willing to spend. Refinishing is typically the more economical choice if you're on a tight budget.

• Cabinet condition. Inspect your cabinets for structural integrity. If they are in good shape, refinishing is likely the best option. However, if they show signs of rot or damage or are outdated in style, it might be time for new cabinets.

• Design goals. Consider what you want to achieve with your cabinet update. If simple color changes are all that's needed, refinishing may suffice. However, new cabinets may be necessary if you're looking for a complete transformation.

• Timeframe. Refinishing typically takes less time than replacing cabinets, so consider how quickly you want the project completed.

• Longevity. Assess the current age and condition of your cabinets and determine if refinishing will extend their lifespan or just be a temporary fix until new ones are needed.

Overall, both options have benefits and drawbacks. When deciding between refinishing or replacing cabinets, it ultimately comes down to individual preferences and priorities. However, it's essential to carefully consider all factors and weigh the costs and benefits before making a final decision. Proper planning lets you achieve a beautiful and functional kitchen within your budget and timeline.

Summary

Refinishing or replacing cabinets is a significant decision that can significantly impact the look and function of your kitchen. By understanding the differences between these two options and considering various factors such as budget, cabinet condition, design goals, timeframe, and longevity, you can make an informed decision that meets your needs.

Whether you refinish or replace your cabinets, remember to thoroughly research materials, finishes, and installation processes to ensure a successful outcome for your cabinet project. So go ahead and give your cabinets the upgrade they deserve! Happy renovating!